From: Exercise and health in frail elderly people: a review of randomized controlled trials
Study | Exercise program | Study follow-up and intervention length | Control group characteristics | Training principles |
---|---|---|---|---|
Binder et al. [14] | Supervised multicomponent training (flexibility, balance, coordination, speed of reaction, strength, and endurance), three times per week during 9 months | 9 months | Low-intensity home-based training (flexibility); 1 h/session, two to three times per week for 9 months | Frequency, duration, intensity, progression, individualization, and specificity |
Ehsani et al. [19] | see Binder et al. [14] | see Binder et al. [14] | see Binder et al. [14] | progression, individualization, frequency, duration, intensity, and specificity |
Brown et al. [15] | Supervised low-intensity multicomponent training, three times per week for 3 months (flexibility, balance, body handling skills, speed of reaction, coordination, and strength) | 3 months | Low-intesity home-based exercise (flexibility); 1 h/session, three times per week for 3 months | Progression, frequency, individualization, and specificity |
Jensen et al. [28] | 11-week supervised multicomponent exercise program (balance, ambulation, strength, endurance, flexibility, and safe movement behavior) executed, in general, two to three times per week, 1–3 h/week | 11-week intervention, 9-month follow-up | Usual care | Progression, individualization, intensity, duration, frequency, and specificity |
Rydwik et al. [29] | Supervised multicomponent exercise program (endurance, strength, and balance), 1 h/session, two times per week for 12 weeks | 3-month intervention, 9-month follow-up | General advice on physical training and diet | Progression, individualization, intensity, duration, frequecy, and specificity |
Timonen et al. [33] | Supervised multicomponent exercise program (resistance training and functional exercises), two times per week, 90 min/session, for 10 weeks | 10-month intervention, 9-month follow-up after intervention | Requested to perform a home-based functional exercise program, two to three times per week | |
Timonen et al. [32] | see Timonen et al. [33] | see Timonen et al. [33] | see Timonen et al. [33] | Progression, individualization, intensity, duration, frequency, and specificity |
Timonen et al. [31] | see Timonen et al. [33] | see Timonen et al. [33] | see Timonen et al. [33] | Progression, individualization, intensity, duration, frequency, and specificity |
Binder et al. [37] | 6 months of supervised multicomponent training (flexibility, balance, coordination, movement speed, strength, and endurance), 45–90 min/session (with possible breaks), three times per week | 6 months | Low-intesity home-based exercise (flexibility); 1 h/session three times per week for 6 months | Progression, individualization frequency, specificity, and duration |
Greenspan et al. [22] | Supervised tai chi exercise (trunk rotation, weight shifting, coordination, and gradual narrowing of the lower extremity stance), two times per week from 10 to 50 min for 48 weeks | 48 weeks | wellness educational program (instructions on falls-prevention, exercise, balance diet, and nutrition) 1 h/week | |
Sattin et al. [25] | see Greenspan et al. [22] | see Greenspan et al. [22] | see Greenspan et al. [22] | |
Wolf et al. [26] | see Greenspan et al. [22] | see Greenspan et al. [22] | see Greenspan et al. [22] | Progression, individualization, duration, frequency, and specificity |
Wolf et al. [36] | see Greenspan et al. [22] | see Greenspan et al. [22] | see Greenspan et al. [22] | Progression, individualization, frequency, duration, and specificity (for some measures) |
Wolf et al. [34] | 15 weeks of supervised tai chi (two times per week; subjects were requested to try two times per day for 15 min—not monitored) or balance training (once per week) | 15-month intervention; 4-month after follow-up | Discussions with a nurse (e.g., sleep disorders), once a week, 1 h/session for 15 weeks | Progression, frequency individualization, and specificity |
Greiwe et al. [23] | Supervised resistance training program, three times per week for 3 months, 50–90 min/session | 3 months | Light stretching program for 3 months | |
Latham et al. [24] | Home-based resistance quadriceps exercise (ankle cuff weights), three times per week during 10 weeks | 10-month intervention, 6-month follow-up | Frequency-matched telephone calls and home visits | Individualization, specificity, intensity, and frequency |
Dorner et al. [27] | three times per week, 50 min/session, of a supervised resistance exercise program focused on strength and balance | 10 weeks | Frequency, duration, and specificity | |
Seynnes et al. [35] | Supervised 10-week resistance training (knee muscles), three times per week | 10 weeks | Placebo exercise (empty cuff weights) | Progression, individualization, intensity, frequency, and specificity |
Miller et al. [38] | Supervised resistance training (hip extensors and abductors, knee extensors, ankle dorsi, and plantar-flexors), three times per week, 20–30 min/session for 12 weeks | 12 weeks | Usual care. matched visits (“attention effect”), three times per week (weeks 1–6); and once a week (weeks 7–12) | Progression, individualization, intensity, duration, frequency, and specificity |
Chin A Paw et al. [16] | Supervised skills training program, two times per week for 17 weeks, 45 min/session (focused on strength, speed, endurance, flexibility, and coordination) | 17 weeks | social program, once or twice a week, 90 min/session (adjustment for socializing and attention effects) | Progression, individualization, duration, frequency, intesity, and specificity |
Chin A Paw et al. [17] | see Chin A Paw et al. [16] | see Chin A Paw et al. [16] | see Chin A Paw et al. [16] | |
de Jong et al. [18] | see Chin A Paw et al. [16] | see Chin A Paw et al. [16] | see Chin A Paw et al. [16] | |
Alexander et al. [39] | Supervised bed- and chair-rise task-specific training with emphasis on strength and range of motion (proximal upper and lower extremity, musculature, and trunk), performed for 12 weeks, three times per week, 1 h/session | 12 weeks | 12-week exercise program focused on flexibility, three times per week, 1 h/session | Progression, individualization, intensity, frequency, duration, and specificity |
Rosendahl et al. [41] | Supervised functional exercise program (everyday tasks challenging leg strength, postural stability, and gait ability) with 45 min/session, five times every 2 weeks for 3 months | 3-month intervention and 6-month follow-up | Social activities (watching films, reading, singing, and conversation) | Progression, individualization, frequency, duration, intensity, and specificity |
Faber et al. [20] | Supervised fall-preventive exercise programs (focused on balance and functional strength, and/or tai chi principles), 60 min/session, once a week for 4 weeks, and two times per week for 16 weeks. | 20-week intervention and 52-week follow-up | Progression, individualization, duration, frequency, and specificity | |
Gill et al. [21] | 6-month home-based exercise program (balance once a day and leg and arm-conditioning and strengthening three times per week); participants received in average 14.9 visits of a physical therapist | 6-month intervention and 12-month follow-up | educational program (attention and health education), 45–60 min/session for 6 months, with visits of a health educator | Individualization, specificity, and frequency |
Gill et al. [40] | see Gill et al. [21] | see Gill et al. [21] | see Gill et al. [21] | Individualization, specificity, and frequency |
Shimada et al. [30] | Two supervised exercise training (balance and gait training), two to three times per week during 40 min/session, for 12 weeks | 12 weeks | Usual care | Individualization, duration, frequency, and specificity |