First author–country | Year | Sample size (men/women) | Fallers, n (%) | Mean age ± SD (min–max) | Judgement criteria | Study quality (ANAES [30]) | Definition of physical activity | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Number | Length | Collection | |||||||
Assantachai–Thailand [60] | 2003 | 1,043 (371/672) | 207 (19.8) | 68.2 ± u.k. (60–u.k.) | 1 fall and + | 6 months | Patient interrogation | 4 | Exercise during the last year |
Brauer–Australia [37] | 2000 | 100 (0/100) | 35 (35.0) | 73 ± 5 (65–86) | 1 fall and + | 6 months | Patient interrogation | 2 | Self reported activity level (>1 h/week) |
Buatois–France [45] | 2006 | 189 (108/81) | 57 (30.2) | 70 ± 4 (66–74) | 1 fall and + | 16 months | Patient interrogation | 4 | Current physical activities |
Chan–Singapore [61] | 1997 | 401 (207/194) | 69 (17.2) | 68.8 ± u.k. (60–90) | 1 fall and + | 1 year | Patient interrogation | 4 | Exercise at least 3 times a week, with each session lasting at 20 min |
Covinsky–USA [38] | 2001 | 557 (187/370) | 123 (22.1) | 81.6 ± u.k. (65–u.k.) | 1 fall and + | 1 year | Patient interrogation | 2 | Aerobic activity ≥1 h/week: walking, swimming, golfing, running, aerobics, dancing and bicycling |
Faulkner–USA [46] | 2007 | 370 (106/264) | 37 (10.0) | 78 ± 3 (74–85) | 2 falls and + | 1 year | Patient interrogation | 4 | Routine walking: walking for exercise; walking to work, store or church; or walking the dog in the previous week and at least 10 times in the previous 12 months |
Herndon–USA [43] | 1997 | 1,158 (292/866) | 467 (40.3) | u.k. ± u.k. (65–u.k.) | Min 1 traumatic fall | 6 months | Patient interrogation | 3 | Current exercise three or more times weekly |
Huang–Taiwan [47] | 2004 | 405 (227/157) | 202 (49.9) | 78 ± u.k. (65–u.k.) | 1 fall and + | 1 year | Patient interrogation | 4 | Type of exercise: moderate range |
Johnson–Canada [48] | 2003 | 96 (17/79) | 30 (31.3) | 82.4 ± 7 (65–98) | 1 fall and + | 4 months | Patient interrogation | 4 | Regular physical activity |
Liu–Canada [39] | 1995 | 100 (17/83) | 59 (59.0) | 83 ± 6 (62–96) | 1 fall and + | 1 year | Notebook patient | 2 | Exercises greater than or equal to once weekly |
Lord–Australia [62] | 1993 | 704 (0/704) | 239 (33.9) | 74.6 ± u.k. (65–99) | 1 fall and + | 1 year | Patient interrogation | 4 | 3+ h planned exercise a week |
Luukinen–Finland [40] | 1996 | 788 (276/512) | 88 (11.2) | 76.1 ± 5 (70–92) | 2 falls and + | 2 years | Patient interrogation | 2 | ≥3 h/week of physical exercise |
Maki–Canada [41] | 1994 | 96 (40/56) | 59 (61.5) | 83 ± 6 (62–96) | 1 fall and + | 1 year | Notebook patient | 2 | Exercise (20 min or more) more than once per week |
Peel–Australia [44] | 2006 | 387 (70/317) | 126 (32.6) | 82.6 ± 7 (65–u.k.) | Min 1 traumatic fall | u.k. | Patient interrogation | 3 | Calculations of sufficient physical activity based on minutes per week spent walking, as well as doing moderate and/or vigorous activity in an average week in the last 6 months; sport involvement over the life stages was also recorded |
Teno–USA [42] | 1990 | 586 (191/395) | 127 (21.7) | 76.5 ± u.k. (65–99) | 2 falls and + | 1 year | Patient interrogation | 2 | To participate in sport activities |
Tinetti–USA [9] | 1988 | 336 (151/185) | 118 (35.1) | 78.5 ± 5 (74–u.k.) | 1 fall and + | 1 year | Patient interrogation | 2 | Weekly walk for exercise + other physical exercise weekly |
Toulotte–France [63] | 2006 | 40 (0/40) | 21 (52.5) | u.k. ± u.k. (60–u.k.) | 1 fall and + | 2 years | Patient interrogation | 4 | Physical activities 2 h/week: walking |