Skip to main content

Table 4 Subgroup analysis of test-retest reliability considering severity of dementia

From: Recommended motor assessments based on psychometric properties in individuals with dementia: a systematic review

 

Mild dementia

Mild to moderate dementia

Moderate dementia

Severity not reported

FICSIT-4

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 22.7 (2.1)

ICC = 0.82

MDC95% = 58.9% [17]

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 19.2 (4.4)

ICC = 0.79

MDC95% = 59.4% [17]

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 15.5 (2.4)

ICC = 0.80

MDC95% = 71.1% [17]

 

GMWT

MMSE [mean (SD)]: n.r.

ICC = 0.79–0.96

MDC95% = n.r [63].

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 17.4 (4.3)

ICC = 0.63–0.94

MDC95% = 31.2–225.7% [63]

MMSE [mean (SD)]: n.r.

ICC = 0.57–0.93

MDC95% = n.r [63].

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 13.8 (5.7)

ICC = 0.96–0.99

MDC95% = 19.6–33.3% [43]

BBS

 

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 20.0 (5.5)

ICC = 0.95

MDC95% = 38.6% [14]

 

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 13.8 (5.7)

ICC = 0.99

MDC95% = 10.2% [43]

6 m WT

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 22.7 (2.1)

ICC = 0.83

MDC95% = 41.5% [17]

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 19.2 (4.4)

ICC = 0.86

MDC95% = 36.5% [17]

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 15.5 (2.4)

ICC = 0.89

MDC95% = 31.6% [17]

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 16.9 (7.3)

ICC = 0.80–0.95

MDC95% = n.r [102].

5x STS

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 21.4 (5.0)

ICC = 0.80

MDC95% = 29.9% [51]

  

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 16.9 (7.3)

ICC = 0.94

MDC95% = n.r [102].

Modified 30s CST

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 22.7 (2.1)

ICC = 0.79

MDC95% = 45.7% [17]

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 19.2 (4.4)

ICC = 0.84

MDC95% = 42.5% [17]

MMSE [mean (SD)]: 15.5 (2.4)

ICC = 0.88

MDC95% = 33.2% [17]

 
  1. 5x STS Five Times Sit-to-Stand Test, 6 m WT 6-m walk test, 30s CST 30-s chair stand test, BBS Berg Balance Scale, FICSIT-4 Frailty and Injuries: Cooperative Studies of Intervention Techniques - subtest 4, GMWT Groningen Meander Walking Test, ICC Intraclass correlation coefficient, MDC95% Percentage minimal detectable changes at 95% confidence interval, MMSE Mini-Mental State Examination, n.r. Not reported, SD Standard deviation.