Skip to main content

Table 3 Summary of usability protocol with supervisors’ observations and participants’ feedback

From: A usability study of a multicomponent video game-based training for older adults

Criteria

Positive aspects

Negative aspects

Functionality and interaction with the system

− Good and stable connection of laptop (with system software) to TVa

− Technical issues (as system crashes or frozen pictures on the screen)a,b

− Simple set upb

− Unstable (Bluetooth) connection of IMUs to the systema,b

− Easy usable game compositionb

− Navigation via laptop keyboard instead by IMUs (as cursors)a

 

− Inaccurate evaluation of movements by IMUs (evaluation algorithms)a

IMUs

− Comfortable to wear (participants did not notice them during training)b

− Suboptimal material of IMU cover (cover expanded after heating up while charging)a

 

− Suboptimal material of IMU fixation strap (difficult to clean the Velcro fixation, material sticks to some clothes)a,b

 

− Difficulties to attach the IMUs with the Velcro fixation (especially at wrists)a,b

Design

− Exciting game story of travelling around Europe to different citiesb

− No variation in musicb

− Pleasant musicb

− No explanation about feedback system (colour code, performance score)b

− Helpful cues (arrows) to prepare the next movementb

 

− Virtual instructor guiding through exercisesb

 

− Helpful indication of number of exercise repetitionsb

 

Training principles

− Visual feedback with colour code (green, orange, red) during exercisingb

− No specific feedback regarding exercise execution and single body part movementsa,b

− Performance score as feedback after exercisingb

− Training load and progression determined by supervisors (no automatic progression)a

 

− Low variability in exercisesa,b

 

− Training load even in high levels not exhausting1,2

Exercises

− Clear structure of exercise levelsb

− No proper introduction of exercises (just start copying the movements of the virtual instructor)a,b

− Complex exercises with additional arm movements provide more fun than simple (boring) movementsb

− Only frontal view of exercises (side view missing)b

 

− No further information about exercise (e.g. muscles involved)b

Emotions

− General enjoyment and funa,b

− Frustrated and displeased by technical issues and inaccurate evaluation of movementsa,b

− Increased motivation through virtual instructor (better than train alone)b

− Missing challenge due to easy exercisesa,b

− Happy when seeing a progress or achieving higher performance scorea,b

− Bored of low training variabilitya,b

  1. IMU Inertial measurement unit. asupervisors’ observations, bparticipants’ feedback.