No. | Author/Year | Outcome | Measurement | Effect Size – within group (Hedges G) | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
T1 | T2 | T3 | ||||
1 | Pinto 2005 [46] | PA time EE PA unit | 7-Day PAR (min/week) 7-Day PAR (kcal/day) Accelerometer (count) | 0.58 0.60 0.43 | 0.71 0.72 0.36 | |
2 | King 2007 [47] | EE PA time EE PA time | CHAMPS (kcal/kg/day) CHAMPS (time/week) 7-Day PAR (kcal/kg/day) 7-Day PAR (min/week) | 0.86 0.84 0.66 0.79 | 1.32 1.24 0.64 0.62 | |
3 | Kolt 2007 [48] | PA time Walk time | AHSPAQ (min/week) AHSPAQ (min/week) | 0.18 0.40 | 0.24 0.19 | 0.35 0.21 |
4 | King 2008 [49] | PA time EE | CHAMPS (min/week) CHAMPS (kcal/kg/week) | 0.77 0.69 | ||
5 | Martinson 2008 [45] | EE | CHAMPS (kcal/week) | −0.03 | ||
6 | Laubach 2009 [50] | Step count | Pedometer (step/day) | 0.50 | ||
7 | Martinson 2010 [51] | EE | CHAMPS (kcal/week) | 0.07 | 0.15 | 0.17 |
8 | Kahlbaugh 2011 [34] | PA unit | WPAS (score) | NA | ||
9 | Van Stralen 2011 [52] | PA time | SQUASH (min/week) | 0.17 | ||
10 | Peels 2013 [35] | PA time | SQUASH (min/week) | NA | ||
11 | Bickmore 2013 [53] | Step count | Pedometer (step/day) | 0.01 | ||
12 | Irvine 2013 [54] | PA time PA frequency | SDQ (min/week) SDQ (count/week) | NA 0.84 | NA 0.79 | |
13 | King 2013 [55] | Step count Walk time | Pedometer (step/day) CHAMPS (min/week) | NA 3.44 | ||
14 | Wijsman 2013 [36] | PA time | Accelerometer (min/day) | NA | ||
15 | Kim 2013 [56] | Step count PA unit | Pedometer (step/day) LTEQ (score) | 0.29 1.86 | ||
16 | Mendelson 2014 [57] | Steps count EE | Accelerometer (step/day) Accelerometer (kcal/week) | −0.06 − 0.05 | ||
17 | Tabak 2014 [58] | PA unit PA unit | BPAQ (score) Accelerometer (count/min) | −0.41 0.13 | 0.07 −0.16 | |
18 | Tabak 2014 [59] | Step count | Accelerometer (step/day) | 0.09 | 0,14 | −0.05 |
19 | Thompson 2014 [42] | PA unit | Accelerometer (unit/day) | −0.14 | ||
20 | Vroege 2014 [60] | PA time | Accelerometer (min/day) | 0.60 | ||
21 | Frederix 2015 [41] | PA time Step count | IPAQ (min/week) Accelerometer (step/day) | NA 11.19a | NA 27.6a | |
22 | Maddison 2015 [61] | PA time Walk time | IPAQ (min/week) IPAQ (min/week) | 0.17 0.13 | ||
23 | Martin 2015 [62] | Step count PA time | Accelerometer (steps/day) Accelerometer (min/day) | 0.39 0.71 | ||
24 | Mouton 2015 [71] | PA time | IPAQ (min/week) | 0.33 | ||
25 | Van de Weegen 2015 [63] | PA time | Accelerometer (min/day) | 0.75 | 0.76 | |
26 | Broekhuizen 2016 [64] | PA time | Accelerometer (min/day) | 0.59 | ||
27 | King 2016 [37] | PA time Sed time Walk time | Accelerometer (min/day) Accelerometer (min/day) Accelerometer (min/day) | |||
28 | Muller 2016 [65] | PA time Sed time | IPAQ-S (min/week) IPAQ-S (hr/day) | 0.75 −0.12 | 0.85 −0.03 | |
29 | Parker 2016 [33] | PA time | EPAP (min/week) | NA | ||
30 | Thakkar 2016 [39] | PA time Sed time | GPAQ(min/week) GPAQ (min/week) | 0.82 NA | ||
31 | Thomsen 2016 [43] | Sed time | ActivPAL3 (hours/day) | −0.15 | ||
32 | Demeyer 2017 [66] | Step count PA time Walk time | Accelerometer (step/day) Accelerometer (min/day) Accelerometer (min/day) | 0.11 0.12 0.19 | ||
33 | Krebs 2017 [44] | PA unit | GLTEQ (MET units/week) | −0.16 | ||
34 | Lyons 2017 [67] | Step count Walk time Sed time | Accelerometer (step/day) Accelerometer (min/day) Accelerometer (min/day) | 0.41 0.58 −0.28 | ||
35 | Nahm 2017 [68] | PA time EE | YPAS (min/week) YPAS (kcal/week) | 0.21 0.21 | ||
36 | Alley 2018 [38] | PA time Step count | Accelerometer (min/day) Accelerometer (step/day) | NA NA | ||
37 | Ellis 2019 [69] | Steps count PA time | Pedometer (step/day) Pedometer (min/day) | 0.01 0.13 | ||
38 | Rowley 2019 [40] | Steps count | Pedometer (step/day) | 2.34a |