Skip to main content

Table 1 Overview of characteristics and results of studies reporting on recommendations regarding physical activity after rehabilitation from total hip or knee arthroplasty

From: Being active with a total hip or knee prosthesis: a systematic review into physical activity and sports recommendations and interventions to improve physical activity behavior

Author (year)

Arthroplasty

Study design

Sample size & characteristics

Data collection period (follow-up & time after surgery)

Type of (sports) activity

Measurement method

Outcome variables of interest

Recommendation

Amstutz and Le Duff [19]

USA

THA

Survey

N = 661 Metal-on-metal hybrid HRA, female 30%, age 51.9 yrs. (14–78), BMI 26.5 (16.7–46.5)

Time after surgery: 10.1 [1–18] yrs

17 general sports activities

Questionnaire

Type, frequency & duration of sporting activities, Survivorship (revision for aseptic failure or wear), Impact & hip cycle scores

Return to sports is safe if treated with well-designed and well-implanted HRA.

Bradley, Moul [20]

Great Britain

THA

Survey

N = 109 British Hip Society members

_

22 general sports activities

Web-based questionnaire

Level of impact (low, intermediate, high), Recommendation (allowed, allowed w experience, not allowed, undecided)

Low-impact sports allowed. Medium-impact sports, ± half of surgeons do not allow high-weight/low-repetition weight-lifting, ice-skating/roller blading. Rowing not allowed by minority of surgeons. High-impact and contact sports, road jogging, martial arts, high-impact aerobics not allowed.

Clifford and Mallon [21]

USA

THA & TKA

Expert opinion

N = 2 Orthopedic surgeons

_

36/37 general sports activities

Consensus

Perceived impact (low, potentially low, intermediate, high)

Low-impact activities allowed, allowed w experience, medium-impact allowed w experience, high-impact not allowed.

Healy, Iorio [22]

USA

THA & TKA

Literature review & survey

N = 54 Hip Society members, N = 58 Knee Society members

–

42 general sports activities

Questionnaire

Recommended/allowed, allowed w experience, no opinion, not recommended

Low-contact/impact sports activity recommended. High-contact/impact activity discouraged

Klein, Levine [23]

USA

THA & TKA

Survey

N = 87 Hip Society members, N = 518 American Association of Hip & Knee Surgeons

_

37 general sports activities

Web-based questionnaire

Allowed, allowed w experience, not allowed, undecided

Low-impact activity allowed, medium-impact allowed or allowed w experience, high-impact not allowed

Laursen, Andersen [24]

Denmark

THA & TKA

Survey

N = 45 Heads of orthopedic departments (performing ≥100 THAs or TKAs per year)

_

31 general sports activities

Questionnaire

Participate regardless of previous experience w activity, participate if person had experience w activity before surgery, do not participate in activity.

87% allow sports, 55% allow high-impact sports post-THA (35% if not experienced), 38% allow high-impact sports post-TKA (22% if not experienced)

McGrory, Stuart [25]

USA

THA & TKA

Review & survey

N = 28 Mayo Clinic orthopedic surgeons, N = 13 consultants, N = 15 fellows or residents

_

28 general sports activities

Computerized literature search to identify citations pertaining to sports and prosthetic hip/knee surgery published between 1966 and 1993.

Questionnaire

Recommended, not recommended, depends

No-impact/low-impact sports encouraged, high-impact prohibited. Results of survey in line with outcome of literature review

Meester, Wagenmakers [26]

Nether-lands

THA & TKA

Survey

N = 117 Dutch Orthopaedic Association members (orthopedic surgeons)

–

40 general sports activities

Web-based survey, distinction made between ages < 65/> 65

Allowed, allowed w experience, discouraged, no advice. Knowledge about and application of international health-enhancing PA recommendations

Low-impact sports allowed. Most ball sports not recommended. Martial arts/contact/high-impact sports discouraged. Majority of surgeons discuss PA. Familiarity with PA recommendations is lacking.

Ollivier, Frey [27]

France

THA

Matched case control study

N = 70 persons doing high-impact sports compared to N = 140 persons doing lower-impact activities

11 yrs. (10–15 yrs)

High-impact sports UCLA score 9–10 & low-impact sports UCLA score 1–4

HHS, HOOS, radiographic analysis (wear rate) and aseptic loosening/need for revision.

Function; dislocation rate; linear wear; survivorship (revision for mechanical failure/radiographic signs of aseptic loosening). Independent risk factors for failure.

Persons doing high-impact sports have better function than persons doing low-impact sports. High-impact sports can lead to mechanical failures.

Payo-Ollero, Alcalde [28]

Spain

THA

Retrospective cohort study

N = 46, n = 13 female (58 hips) age 41 yrs. (37–48)

Average follow-up 7.5 years (1–11)

General

sports activities

Telephone questionnaire

Sports recommended or advised against

Low-impact sports recommended (swimming, static biking, daily walking) Sports w high impact on hip not recommended. Contact sports allowed w previous experience.

Swanson, Schmalzried [29]

USA

THA & TKA

Survey

N = 139 American Association for Hip and Knee Surgeons members (orthopedic surgeons)

–

15 general sports activities

Questionnaire

Unlimited, occasional [1–2 times/month], discouraged

Low-impact sports allowed. No consensus on medium-impact sports. High-impact sports discouraged. THA recommendations more liberal compared to TKA.

Thaler, Khosravi [30]

Europe

THA

Survey

N = 150 European Hip Society members

–

47 general sports activities

Web-based questionnaire

Allowed, allowed if experienced, not allowed, no opinion. 4 time frames: within 6 weeks post-THA, 6–12 weeks post-THA, 3–6 months post-THA, more than 6 months post-THA.

Most physical activities were allowed 6 months post-THA. Experience in performing a distinct sport activity did not influence the recommendations to return to previous sports activities. Handball, soccer, football, basketball, full-contact sports, and martial arts not allowed.

Thaler, Khosravi [31]

Europe

TKA

Survey

N = 120 European Knee Associates members (surgeons)

–

47 general sports activities

Web-based questionnaire

Allowed, allowed if experienced. Not allowed, no opinion. 4 time frames: within 6 weeks post-TKA, 6–12 weeks post-TKA, 3–6 months post-TKA. more than 6 months post-TKA.

Consensus for recommendation to allow 5 different sports in first 6 weeks, 7 sports at 6–12 weeks, 14 sports at 3–6 months, and 21 out of 47 activities 6 months postop. Number of sports recommended increases stepwise over postop time frames.

Vu-Han, Gwinner [32]

Germany

TKA

Survey

N-101 German Arthroplasty Society members (surgeons)

 

30 general sports activities

Questionnaire

Recommendation: undecided, not recommended, w training, w.o. limitations

53.5% of surgeons recommend high-impact sports with adequate training, 36.6% do not recommend it at all, 5.9% recommend high-impact sports w.o. limitations. Most low-impact sports recommended after 3 months, while high-impact sports require at least 6 months of rehabilitation or rather not recommended at all.

Vu-Han, Hardt [33]

Germany

THA

Survey

N = 99 German Arthroplasty Society members (surgeons)

–

30 general sports activities

Questionnaire

Recommendation: undecided, not recommended, w training, w.o. limitations

Low-impact sports recommended w.o. limitations and within 3 months post-THA. Return to high-impact sports advised by 51.5% of surgeons if the person received adequate training, 8.1% w.o. limitations, 34.3% did not recommend high-impact sports at all (3% left it up to the person). For high-impact sports, most experts recommended at least 6 months before return to sports. Basketball, boxing, soccer, gymnastics, handball, hockey, squash, climbing, volleyball, tennis and slope-skiing mostly not recommended or only w adequate training. Walking, swimming, hiking and level biking were activities the vast majority of surgeons recommended w.o. limitations or training. Recommendations seemed to vary for ballroom dancing, cross-country biking, bowling, dancing, e-scooters, fitness/weights, golf, horseback riding, jogging. Pilates, cross-country skiing, table tennis and yoga recommended w.o. limitations or w adequate training.

Witjes, Hoorntje [34]

Nether

lands

TKA & UKA

Survey

N = 82 Physiotherapists

–

32 general sports activities

Web-based questionnaire

Recommended, recommended w experience, possible but not recommended, impossible

Low-impact sports recommended. Medium/high-impact sports not recommended/considered impossible. More liberal in return to sports post-UKA than post-TKA.

Specific activities

 Gschwend, Frei [35]

Switzerland

THA

Case control study

Group A: N = 50 regular alpine skiing and/or cross-country skiing, age 65 yrs. (47–84), weight 77 kg (44–100), height 1.73 m (148–193)

Group B: N = 50, did no winter sports, age 65 yrs. (42–79), weight 78 kg (52–110), height 1.72 m (150–189)

10 yrs., measurements at 5 and 10 yrs

Alpine skiing and/or cross-country skiing

5-yr measurement: physical examination, questionnaire (hip, back, knee pain), radiographic examination (presence/location & extent of radiolucent lines, migration, tilting, subsidence). Rate of polyethylene wear (method Scheier et al. (1976)). 10-yr measurement: questionnaire/clinical/radiographic examination

Loosening & wear

Controlled alpine and/or cross-country skiing has no negative effect on acetabular or femoral component of hip replacements. Short-radius turns on steep slopes or moguls must be avoided.

 Hara, Nakashima [36]

Japan

THA

Laboratory study

N = 9 33% female, age 66 yrs. (55–84), BMI 25.0 kg/m2 (17.5–30.2)

Time after surgery: 4.8 [0.5–13.7] yrs

Golf

Kinematics

Hip kinematics during golf swing (hip movements, liner-to-neck contact & cup-head translation)

Golf is admissible due to dynamic hip stability.

 Kloen, De Man [37]

Netherlands

THA

Cohort study & literature review

N = 9 alpine skiers, 34% female, age 59.4 yrs. (47–70), weight 73 kg (52–95)

5.9 (1–13 yrs)

Alpine skiing

HHS, self-constructed questionnaire (downhill skiing-specific issues), radiographic analysis (weight-bearing AP/pelvic view, AP/lateral hip view)

Loosening, migration & wear

Downhill skiing is feasible, but ski with long turns on groomed slopes.

 Mont, Rajadhaksha [38]

USA

TKA

Survey

N = 33 (46 TKAs), United States Tennis Association high-level tennis players, 15% female, age 64 yrs. (30–79)

Time after surgery 7 yrs. (2–18)

High-level tennis

Questionnaire on clinical data of the TKA, general & sport-specific questions on tennis.

Surgeon’s advice on playing tennis. Years playing tennis, level, frequency, single/double. Stiffness and pain in mobility parameters (e.g. hitting, running, ground strokes, moving forward after serves to volley).

21% of surgeons approve playing tennis, 45% recommend only doubles, 55% oppose playing any tennis. High-level players were able to perform at preop level post-TKA. Players were satisfied with the TKA and ability to resume playing tennis.

 Mont, LaPorte [39]

USA

THA

Survey

N = 58 (65 THAs), United States Tennis Association players, 14% female, age 70 yrs. (47–89)

Time after surgery 8 yrs. (2–22)

Competitive tennis

Questionnaire on clinical data of the THA, general & sport-specific questions on tennis.

Surgeon’s advice on playing tennis. Years playing tennis, level, frequency, single/double. Stiffness and pain in mobility parameters (e.g. stroke by stroke, from follow-through to shifting weight into their stroke, mobility around the court).

14% of surgeons approve playing tennis, 34% recommend only doubles, 52% oppose playing any tennis. Players were extremely satisfied with their THA and their increased ability to participate in tennis. This select group of competitive players were able to perform at a better level post-THA than preoperatively.

  1. AP = anterior posterior; BMI = body mass index; HHS=Harris Hip Score; HOOS=Hip Disability and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score; HRA = hip resurfacing arthroplasty; KG = kilogram; M = meters; N = number; THA = total hip arthroplasty; TKA = total knee arthroplasty; UCLA = University of California, Los Angeles; UKA = unicompartmental knee arthroplasty; w = with; w.o. = without; yrs. = years